Sunday, May 9, 2021

Mathematics Research and Reflections

Maths Q + A 

Recently I watched a Q & A session on tvnzondemand (link to episode), specifically relating to mathematics teaching in New Zealand. The Q & A session delved into our current mathematics data including; 

  • Where New Zealand is sitting in comparison to the world
  • The decline in our maths results over the last 20 years 

The Q & A also looked in to our methods of teaching and how they have changed. 

On the Q & A there was a group of panellists, ranging from researchers in mathematics, a teacher and principal, DMIC founder Bobbie Hunter and NZEI President Liam Rutherford. 

It was quite shocking to see how far New Zealand has slipped in their mathematics over the last 20 years, especially compared to other countries. It made me think about what we have been doing over the last 20 years - what is not working and what are other countries doing to bring their mathematics achievement up. 

An alarming statistic that stood out to me as a Year 7/8 teacher was that only 45% of our students are at or above the current curriculum level . In addition to this, according to TIMSS (trends in mathematics and statistics), New Zealand is tracking lower than Australia, England and Singapore to name a few. This got me thinking, what can we do that other countries have in place to lift our mathematics achievement? 

The panellists all has differing views on the ways we should teach mathematics, however, they were all agreed on one thing - this is a big issue in education in New Zealand. 

Both the traditional approach to teaching mathematics was considered and was the preferred way of teaching by some of the panellists - where students were 'drilled' into learning their mathematics by rote learning. Practice and repetition was highly valued (this reminded me of Malcolm Gladwells 10,000 rule). 

In opposition to this was a more open approach to mathematics, this discussion was particularly led by Bobbie Hunter where students learn through open ended mathematics problems that relate more to real life problems. Students are encouraged to talk about their mathematical thinking, struggle with problems and test out different methods - this suggests a more creative inquiry based approach to teaching mathematics. 

Watching this Q & A gave me the opportunity to reflect on mathematics in my current school and what we can do to raise our mathematics achievement. I have recently joined the school 'maths team' and I am looking forward to reflecting on our current programme and making changes based off research. 

One aspect we are looking at changing at our school is through using DMIC. I'm not sure if this is the direction we will go in, but listening to Bobbie Hunter's perception of how mathematics should be taught was interesting. What stood out to me in the Q & A was that we need to prepare our students for their futures. They need to be solving problems that will relate to their lives later on, they need to see the relevance of mathematics in their life and they need to be confidence approaching problems that they may not know how to solve - grit and perseverance are important skills to develop. 

However, on the flip side, I also see the importance of students knowing their basic facts, time tables, place value, decimals and fractions - they need this mathematics knowledge concrete in their head, so when they go to solve real life problems, they have a solid kete of knowledge to use. 

I see both sides to the panel and am keen to merge them together to create a project that will facilitate the teaching of mathematics knowledge to our students. 


Maths Reading Reflection

In addition to the Q & A, I have been reading Mathematical Mindsets by Jo Boaler. I have read the first three chapters; The Brain and Mathematical Learning, The Power of Mistakes and Struggle and The Creativity and Beauty in Mathematics. I have found this book to be very interesting, it highlights the importance of mindset within mathematics. We need to grow this growth mindset (Carol Dweck), it stipulates that everyone is capable of being a mathematician and we need to make this clear to our learners. The language we use, the problems we give them, the way we praise and the way we discus mathematics is very important. 


The book states, mistakes and struggle are both essential to mathematics learning - these need to be explained and valued when learning math. This is how we learn. The science behind this research is further explained in the book, which brings a very compelling argument to the way we teach mathematics. 

Creativity within mathematics is also highlighted. The importance of not only looking at maths in terms of numbers, but also through patterns. Mathematics is all around us, for example in nature - this is discussed further in the book. 

What I liked about this book was that it challenged the way mathematics is taught currently at school. It stated that we are not teaching students enough of the mathematics they need for their futures - we need to look at it differently. 

Furthermore, I also liked how it talked about the creative elements to mathematics - so often mathematics is thought of as either right/wrong. I thought this way for a long time as well, however there are many different elements to mathematics and we need to start looking at it in a different light. I liked that this book stated its fine to be wrong or even to not know the answer - talking and discussion with others is how we learn. 

Most of all, my favourite part of the book was mindset. I strongly believe a growth mindset is essential to success. We need to teach students about belief, grit, perseverance, determination and the importance of these elements - all students need to know they can succeed. 

In regards to my MIT project, I need to consider my next steps and think about what direction I want to take it. I know that mathematics knowledge is incredibly important to develop within our students - the context in which I teach this needs to be investigated. 

My next piece of research will be through looking into the Prismatic​ Journal (Practice and Research in Statistics and Mathematics Education) to see their recommendations. 

Wednesday, April 7, 2021

MIT2021 - Project Data Collection

Now that I have identified my challenge, I have started to collect some data from my Year 7/8 students to help guide my project. This data will help to identify the gaps and and the specific challenges my students have within maths. I collected the following data;

  • PAT Data
  • GloSS Data
  • Maths Knowledge Assessment (SFOA Progressions specific)
  • Student and teacher voice
  • I looked into our SFOA mathematics digital progressions\
PAT Data
                                      
This data shows our Year 7/8 PAT data - students that were above or below the national average.  

                                              
Within this PAT Data, I looked specifically into the goals that aligned with maths knowledge. I identified what elements of maths knowledge our students struggled with. 

Student and Teacher Voice



From this data I had the following wonderings and reflections; 

Wonderings
  • Teachers lack of understanding of the goals - not sure or wanting to 'tick' it off based off their understanding of the goal. 
  • Huge discrepancies between level 3 and 4 digital progressions. 
  • Variances in different knowledge data - some goals stronger than others. 
  • Basic facts data - concerning, especially in relation to maths strategy. 
  • A lot of our students don't like learning about  proportions and ratios - the data shows a lack of understanding around basic fraction understanding - could this contribute?
Reflections
  • Maths team - I have recently joined the school maths team. We are looking into how maths is taught across the school and what needs to change/what we need to look into and research. Some of the elements of our school wide maths that we are diving into includes; the consistency of maths teaching across hubs, the digital learning progressions and possible tools we can integrate into our maths i.e. DIMIC. 
  • I think my plans are realistic - I would like to do something for the year 5/6 team and year 7/8, but I'm not sure if this is realistic enough for this year. could just trial within year 7/8?

KPMG Term 1 Hui Reflection

Our MIT group met together for our second design thinking session on Monday 29 March. Our Hui was held at KPMG in Auckland. We spent the day revisiting our projects as a group since out last Hui using the following WWW questions.

  • Whats working?
  • Whats not - barriers/road bumps
  • What opportunities do you sense?
We then referred back to our 'crazy 8s' from our last Hui and started to experiment, prototype and test our current ideas. 


Reflection

We started by reflecting on the design thinking process (refer to this link for more information on the design thinking process - User Testing: A Guide To Step 5 Of The Design Thinking Process) from last session and used the following questions to guide our reflections;

What's working?

    • Great support from team members. 
    • I now have a better understanding of our mathematics data. 
    • Student voice - was very interesting and informative. 
    • Started looking at different approaches to this challenge - how can we change what we have been doing and getting students more engaged.
What's not?
    • Need to clarify in my mind what I want to create. Look into why other things haven't helped in the past.
What's next?
    • Look into different tools that have already been created that I would like to base my idea off i.e. Tipu
    • What do I need to learn to create this tool? 
    • Feedback from our school maths team?
Current Challenge Statement
  • My initial challenge statement
    • "A significant number of our 2021 Year 7/8 cohort are below curriculum level expectation in Mathematics, due to gaps in their maths knowledge". 
    • Initially at the start of today's session, my challenge statement had not changed. However, reflecting on today's session it will need to be modified. I will explain this in more detail later in this post. 
Gelling Process

In this 'gelling process' this helped me to challenge my current thinking and make changes based off my current data and feedback from MIT colleagues. It helped to 'flesh' out my challenge and look at the real issues within it - what do I need to overcome or learn about to make this project a success?

I found it particularly interesting listening to Sarah's project - it is very similar to my current challenge, however she is working with year 5/6's. After chatting to her and gaining some insight/perspective from Matt and Dorothy, we have decided to collaborate for our projects for the year. I think that by working together we will be able to achieve more (across a broader range of curriculum levels) and will be able to draw on each other to create something really valuable for our learners. 

Drawing it up

Once making the decision to work with Sarah, we started working on our project and talking through out ideas. We talked with Matt around some ideas we can use for our project. He showed us an interesting way we can use google sheets to create a question where the numbers change each time the page is refreshed. 




The image above shows Sarah and I's thinking for our project. It shows the areas we want to go and our identified next steps. There is still a lot to work through and decide on, however, our idea at the moment is to create a maths site for students to access and work independently on maths strategy and knowledge work. 

Prototyping

I really enjoyed drawing up a plan for our site. We have tried to keep it relatively simple and user friendly (i.e. maximum of 3 clicks) for the students. There are a range of elements we want to incorporate into our project and site, however,  we need to assess what is achievable in the time we have. Incorporating in video tutorials, a google form where people can submit their own questions, making the questions as multi-modal as possible and deciding what type of assessment to use are all aspects of our project we will need to consider. 


Progress update


After our session today we wrote down some next steps, they are as follows;
  • Learn how to code the google sheets with the changing maths questions
  • Sort out what specific goals/progressions we want to incorporate
  • Rethink our challenge question
  • Decide on a name

Next next steps;
Consider the following;
  • Video tutorials
  • How to make the questions multi-modal i.e. use of mote?
  • Create some questions and think about formatting
  • Consider how assessment will be incorporated

Sarah and I plan to meet to unpack some of these next steps together and see where our project goes.

Monday, March 8, 2021

Design Thinking: Ideation

Our final Design Thinking challenge for the weekend was to create a 'Crazy 8's poster'. 

The purpose of this task was to come up with 8 ideas individually to solve our challenge. My ideas are as follows;

  • Track trends
  • Set up a maths knowledge programme for the senior school
  • Create a game to gamify maths knowledge '
  • Create a maths knowledge site
  • Create a maths app
  • Set up a maths team
  • Student led workshops
  • Mindset programme


Once we had come up with 8 ideas, we went around everyones 'Crazy 8's' and put a gold circle sticker on any of the ideas we liked. Once we had done this, we put one final 'special' sticker on the idea we liked the best. 

It was really interesting and it surprised me with what ideas people liked. They differed to my own preference - but has made me think about how I can incorporate both sets of thinking for my final challenge design. 

Design Thinking: Who

Our next Design Thinking session was called 'Who'. We had to create a 'Who' poster where we identified the people that could help us with our projects. My poster is attached below.  


The different colours within the poster represent the process of our thinking. Written in black - this is where I started. I identified the people close to me that could help me with my project, these people ranged from my colleagues at school and the individual skills they could help me with, to my learners and further to my fellow MIT colleagues. These people are all very close to me and will be a big part of my project. 

As my thinking developed as did the possibilities. Written in yellow are the people one step further. These are the people that are not within my immediate life - but people that I could possibly get in touch with to further help my project. One thing to note here, was that a few of these people have been crossed off - we had to take away at least one person, to limit our people down and think critically about who could provide the best help. 

The final writing in blue represents our big picture thinking. Out of anyone in the world - Who would I want to help with me project? I chose a range of people - ranging from educators i find inspiring, to maths guru's, to google employees to Albert Einstein.... The people I chose in this category inspire me a lot within my teaching and I would love to get their perspective on my identified challenge.  

Friday, March 5, 2021

Design Thinking: Interpretation

Our next exercise was to dive deeper into everyones challenges and ask the following question 'How might we turn this problem into an Opportunity' . On post it notes, everyone went around each others challenges and asked a 'How might we....' question to try and stimulate some thinking around how we can get the most out of this challenge. 



Some of the 'How might we' questions that really resonated with me were as follows;

  • HMW look at patterns and collective gaps leading up to Yr 7/8 to better target the problem later on.
  • HMW address this as a wide or whole school approach - could intervention be made earlier (before Yr 7/8) or could consistent strategies be used across years?

Wednesday, March 3, 2021

Design Thinking: Discovery

Our second session of our Design Thinking was called 'Discovery'. In this session we went through a role play activity at the fictional 'Kuaotunu area school'. 

The context for this session was a teacher/parent information session, where the Principal was reporting to the parents some of the issues at the school. We were all given a role to play for the session, these roles ranged from a parent who was a lawyer to the local plumber. The Principal reported the school's issues (our identified challenges) and within our roles we had to question these challenges and talk through why they were a potential problem. 

This was a great session as it helped to show and clarify to others what our challenge is and why it is a challenge. It was great to get the perspectives from the other teachers in the room - especially in their role playing character. I think it highlighted to me, that this is an issue among our students and there are so many possible reasons as to why this has occurred, but also so many possibilities to remedy it. The perspectives of my other MIT colleagues helped me to see that. 

I am looking forward to seeing where this challenge will go - especially with the help of my other MIT colleagues.